Circuit VR: The Wheatstone Bridge Analog Laptop or computer

Table of Contents

We are constantly amazed with one thing so simple can basically be so advanced. For case in point, what would you assume goes into an analog laptop or computer? Of course, a “real” analog computer system has opamps that can do logarithms, square roots, multiply, and divide. But would it surprise you that you can make an analog device like a slide rule utilizing a Wheatstone bridge — essentially two voltage dividers. You never even want any active devices at all. It is an aged idea and 1 that made use of to demonstrate up in electronic magazines now and all over again. I’ll show you how they do the job and simulate the device so you do not have to establish it except you just want to.

A voltage divider is a person of the best circuits in the world to evaluate. Contemplate two resistors Ra and Rb in collection. Voltage arrives in at the prime of Ra and the base of Rb is grounded. The node connecting Ra and Rb — let’s contact it Z — is what we’ll contemplate the output.

Let’s say we have a 10 V battery feeding A and a excellent voltmeter that does not load the circuit linked to Z. By Kirchoff’s present legislation we know the recent through Ra and Rb need to be the similar. Right after all, there is nowhere else for it to go. We also know the voltage drop across Ra additionally the voltage drop across Rb ought to equivalent to 10 V. Kirchoff, conservation of electrical power, no matter what you want to phone it.  Let us get in touch with these portions I, Va, and Vb.

There are several strategies to go from listed here, but let’s take that the existing as a result of two collection resistors will be the same as if it had been one particular resistor of equivalent value. That is, a 1 KΩ and a 2 KΩ resistor in series will draw as substantially recent as a 3 KΩ resistor. That usually means Ohm’s law tells us:

I = 10/(Ra+Rb)

Now you can address for each and every voltage fall:

Va = I Ra

Vb = I Rb

In point, our voltmeter at Z will measure Vb because it is grounded.

Significant Furry Deal

Of course, you probably know about voltage dividers. But we had been going to speak about Wheatstone bridges. The fact is these are just two voltage dividers in parallel and you evaluate the voltage amongst the two outputs (call them Z1 and Z2). You frequently see this circuit drawn like a diamond, but really don’t permit that idiot you. It is nonetheless just two voltage dividers.

With no applying any math, you can see that if the voltage dividers are the identical then Z1 and Z2 will be the same and, thus, no recent will move due to the fact the voltage concerning the two points is zero. What transpires when the divider is not the very same? There will be far more voltage on a single Z stage than the other.

Traditionally, this was made use of to measure resistance. You could use two matched resistors in element of the bridge, have an mysterious resistance in a person of the remaining legs and a variable resistor with a dial calibrated to go through ohms. You’d switch the dial right until a meter read through zero and examine the resistance benefit from the dial. If the ability supply is AC, you can also measure reactance utilizing a equivalent circuit.

But the Slide Rule?

So how do you get from a piece of antique take a look at equipment to a slide rule? Let us alter the bridge so the left-hand divider has resistors Ra and Rb whilst the other 1 has Rc and Rd. We can seem at the algebra:

Z1=V (Rb/(Ra + Rb))

Z2=V (Rd/(Rc + Rd))

We want Z1 to equal Z2 so:

V (Rb/(Ra + Rb)) = V (Rd/(Rc + Rd))

We can divide each sides by V and get rid of that expression:

(Rb/(Ra + Rb)) = (Rd/(Rc + Rd))

So to stability the bridge we need to have:

(Ra + Rb)/Rb  = (Rc + Rd)/Rd    reciprocal the two sides

(Ra Rd + Rb Rd) = (Rc Rb + Rb Rd)    multiply the two sides by Rb Rd

Ra Rd = Rc Rb      subtract Rb Rd from both sides

Ra = (Rb Rc)/Rd    Remedy for Ra

As a easy thought experiment, then, visualize that Rd=1. If you established Rb and Rc then you can alter Ra to stability and the price of Ra will be the remedy. Or you can established Rb to 1 and enter figures in Rc and Rd. When you stability Ra, you will know the end result of the division.

In practice, while, you might want to scale the outcome, primarily for division. For case in point, if Rb=1, Rc=2, and Rd=1000 you would require to established A to .002 ohms which is really hard to do. In that situation, even though, you could established Rb to a scale variable. If it have been, say, 10K, then Ra can be set to 20 ohms.


You could crack out a handful of potentiometers and have a go at this. We’d advise linear kinds unless of course you are pretty helpful at producing logarithmic scale dials. But given that this is Circuit VR, we’d relatively do a simulation. Falstad matches the bill, but any simulator is effectively up to the activity.

Analog slide rule simulation

There are two switches in the simulation. The top rated “C” switch allows you swap in the top resistor or a 10X, 100X, or 1000X array resistor for C. The bottom “D” change lets you decide on a 1 ohm resistor or a variable resistor for D. The ammeter in the centre exhibits the bridge balance and will browse 0A when you are in equilibrium.

Talking of variable resistors, I did place sliders for each and every of the resistors on the correct sidebar of the simulator. Nonetheless, working with them typically puts values in like 10.002K which reads 10K on the display screen and is a supply of error. Of program, you’d have the exact difficulty with genuine pots, so possibly which is a excellent simulation. Nevertheless, it is much better to double click the resistor you want to alter and enter its price specifically. Obviously, you shouldn’t transform the three fastened C resistors or the set D resistor.

Up coming Methods

A very similar unit in a 1960 Radio Electronics

If you want to see what this circuit appeared like in the flesh, verify out webpages 48 and 49 of the June 1960 Radio Electronics. It may well have even been the extremely report that spawned [Bil Herd’s] very first laptop package. A identical kit from Edmund Scientific utilized three potentiometers to variety the bridge in a typical configuration. We’ve even viewed a edition from GE that utilised an audio oscillator so you could listen to the null point making use of headphones. You can see both of those of people on the posting starting off on webpage 65 of the December 1961 Common Electronics. Or test out a newer make in excess of on

It would be an easy enough wet day undertaking. If you have an previous-fashioned mirror scale meter from an old multimeter, it would actually shine in this application. Making the dials in a CAD program and printing them out would be effortless, too.

If you want a challenge, why not use an AC source together with variable capacitors and inductors to make a sophisticated variety calculator? That’d be one thing and if you pull it off, we’d cover it.

In the meantime, we’d like to point out that real analog desktops have been not this basic. On the other hand, by definition, this is an analog computer just like a serious slide rule. If you go through the Radio Electronics report, you will see it can even chain an respond to into the subsequent trouble just like you would do on a slipstick.